
BURN THE BURKA?
Choosing between Two Liberties
Nicolas Sarkozy’s comment two weeks ago has caused quite a stir amongst Europeans who live in a continent that is becoming less European every year. In an address to Parliament, the French President attacked the Muslim women's dress, the burka saying,
"We cannot accept to have in our country women who are prisoners behind netting, cut off from all social life, deprived of identity"
The French National Assembly announced on 23 June, one day after Sarkozy's address, the creation of an inquiry into whether women in France should be allowed to wear the burka.This problem stems from the decades long policy of opening Europe’s borders to "the tired, the poor". Coupled with this, the veiling of women from a liberal society has isolated them further and limited their chances of getting out of an economic rut.
Yet in a country that has no problem with topless sun-bathers and tolerates Eurotrash couture, the knee-jerk impatience when seeing a Muslim woman in a veil seems to be on the complete opposite spectrum of liberty and contrary to the idea of letting people live in the pursuit of their own destiny.
A disdain for people’s beliefs and dress is a trademark of Arab countries and nations from where these very immigrants come. Surely Europe does not want to emulate the Saudi’s and Iranians? Some say that if one chooses to dress in a burka then one should return to their home countries where it is acceptable. Yet is this what the founders of the French Revolution envisioned their revolution to be? Is the mother of the modern world turning its back on people who do not fit into the classic European mould?
What will be next? Will circumcision be considered too barbaric and wearing symbols around one’s neck too aggressive as an expression the right of freedom of association? Already, in 2004, France banned the Islamic headscarf and other conspicuous religious symbols from public schools, triggering heated debate in the country and abroad.
There is a fine line and the burka is on the extreme end as a symbol of imposed male repression that should be frowned upon in society, and discouraged by true libertarians. But this is a catch 22 as these very libertarians have a duty to fight for the right of those who choose to wear a Burka, Armish hats or high heels.
The way to remove the burka from French society is to do what Napoleon did and drown it out with emancipation and fraternity rather than with the constriction of freedom which is the trademark of governments of the Arab world.
It is not whether a choice is right or wrong in the end but it is the process of choice itself that defines the liberty. While the burka is the symbol of repression, we cannot use repressive means to deny people of their choices.